Execution Controversy

Let’s talk Troy Davis. Quite a few friends on Facebook are trying to compare the case to the Casey Anthony verdict saying that “CA can walk the streets while TD is dying. unfair.”

These cases are so wildly not similar that I won’t even credit that with a response. Your statement is awarded no points. We are all dumber for having read it and may god have mercy on your soul.

The other post I have seen tonight is, “y is killing cops different from killing other people? What makes cops special?”

I’m sorry folks. I bit the bait on this one and responded.

‎”‘Y is it that a cops.life is more important than any other human life?’ Really? Do you think that is the major issue here? The reason society holds different standards is that there is a deterrence to the killing of a cop that is necessitated so as to stem violence against those who uphold the statutes in our respective states. The guy flipping fries at mcdonalds is not held to the same standards as police officers and doesn’t uphold law or keep peace. The Police do. By killing a police officer, a person is shooting at the government itself. The real question here is matter of evidence, not the social norms we place on society in our execution of sentencing. The man was given ample time to appeal the decision. The system, as JG said, is flawed. Question the system. It is good to do that. We are called as citizens to do this.”

While my response is filled with a few holes and I wrote it hastily, I think that will give the poster something to chew on for a few minutes anyway.

If the man is innocent the system is at blame: if the man is guilty the system is at blame.

Understanding my place in law school is harder when I think about these types of things. Some day, through no action of my own, I may be forced to prosecute a defendant to the death penalty. I may be able to defend a man and successfully keep him from being executed. That is a heavy topic to think about as I read about jurisdiction and minor torts like trespass to chattles.

~YJ_SL

 

About these ads

Leave a Comment

Filed under Blawg, Law, Law School

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s